Highest Rated

Heaven Hill William Heavenhill Small Batch  •  8/28/2014  •  5.0

Smooth, consistent not harsh. Chocolate and nutty aroma and flavors. Solid smooth straight drinking bourbon.

Caol Ila 14 Year Old “Unpeated Style” 2012 Special Release  •  6/29/2016  •  4.5

Apple and other fruit. I think I tasted a bit of seaweed. Initial burst of fruit which becomes particularly lemony with time. Finish is long and consistent with notes of pepper.

Bunnahabhain1989 25 Year Old Signatory Bottling  •  6/29/2016  •  4.5

Sherry, toffee and leather followed by cinnamon and the faintest hint of cardamon. Fruit and sweetness sugar, chestnuts and raisins, mixed spice, nutmeg and caramel lingering for long after the final sip.

Lowest Rated

Glenkinchie 12  •  10/30/2014  •  2.0

Smooth, even. I would enjoy drinking this as a daily scotch. Doesn't wow me, but it's nice with water.

Batch 206 Distillery Barrel Raider Bourbon Whiskey  •  10/30/2014  •  2.0

Mild bourbon! Nothing to write home about. Its young and doesn't have a charred oak flavor. Would make a decent Manhattan.

The Arran Malt 17 Year  •  11/20/2014  •  2.5

Cinnamon, spicy. Almost astringent. A little brown sugar. Strong nose.


Before you go, check out more —