Highest Rated
Benriach 35 • 8/25/2016 • 5.0
Sweet on the nose. Like walking through a caramel factory. Wow, I love this. Either I haven't had a good tasting in a while or the spirit is world class. Sweet and explosive in a good way.
Macallan 18 • 10/29/2015 • 5.0
Smells sweet. Am I about to eat candy? No, but the taste is much sweeter than other spirits I've tried tonight. Dark cherry, almond, vanilla are the flavor I get. I love this, tastes great and I could drink it every day.
SMWS 71.38: A Cheese Board in a Library • 6/25/2014 • 5.0
Interestingly, I get no aroma in this one other than alcohol. Drinking this instantly reminds me of taffy. Caramel hints, toffee, popcorn, and bark. Adding water opened up a creamy nose.
Lowest Rated
A.D. Rattray Cask Collection BenRiach 23 • 2/25/2016 • 2.0
Smells subtle, almost nothing at all on the nose. But when you take the first sip, it's pretty strong. Bitter, like tree bark. It has a punch and because of that it's hard to find the palette.
Old Monk Rum • 10/30/2014 • 2.0
Smells lovely, like caramel candy and fire. I thought it's taste the same but its much more bland than its smell. Easy to drink.
Becherovka • 2/26/2015 • 2.5
Absinthe. That's what I immediately think of when smelling this. Once drinking, I sum this up as "Christmas in a bottle."
