Highest Rated

Macallan 18  •  10/29/2015  •  5.0

You minx! You are back. I lost my whisky cherry to you all those many years ago. I almost forgot about you - but we all know that could never happen. Welcome back, me.

Ardbeg Supernova 2014  •  12/18/2014  •  5.0

Leather, spice, oils, dark chocolate. Hangs on the tongue in a way that I want to lick the roof of my mouth for several days for the lingering sweetness and peat. Best for: blowing the doors off

Buffalo Trace Seattle Spirits Society Single Barrel Select Bourbon  •  1/28/2016  •  4.5

If the consistent excellence of Buffalo Trace could possibly be raised, it has happened here.

Lowest Rated

Defiant American Single Malt Whisky  •  5/29/2014  •  1.5

Menthol. You could light my breath on fire.

Charbay Whiskey Release III  •  1/28/2016  •  2.0

The most highly charactered whiskey one can try. Prost in a dram.

Old Potrero 18th Century Style Whiskey  •  6/24/2015  •  2.0

Atomic fire balls. That's all you can expect from this rye, likely enhanced by the toasted and not fully charred oak barrels.


Before you go, check out more —