3.11/5
RATING

Old Overholt

3 Years Old
40% ABV
$20

Old Overholt was tasted at Meeting No. 32 on January 29, 2015. Out of 5, we rated it very highly at 3.11. Old Overholt ranks 20th overall in American Whiskey. Costing $20, this spirit is an extraordinary value.

Rating Details

AVERAGE
RATING
3.11/5
FOUNDERS
3.36/5
MEMBERS
2.96/5
AGREEMENT
VALUE
RANK
No. 20 of 36
BEST FOR

Tasting Notes

First Tasted at Meeting No. 32 in January 2015

Elliott  •  1/29/2015  •  4.0

Cedary dry wood and and nutmeg. Reminds me of the Cascades during the summer. Great bargain buy. Will be adding this to the cabinet. Like Top Pot's Pershing doughnut.

Gavin  •  1/29/2015  •  3.5

Balanced banana wrapped in a blanket of musty porridge mammatus.

Marco  •  1/29/2015  •  3.0

Cinnamon nose jumps out but taste is surprisingly pleasant and easy to drink.

Brian R.  •  1/29/2015  •  3.0

Oak and woodchips. Sticky sweet, piney, glazed donut.

Steven  •  1/29/2015  •  3.0

Solid cheap spicy rye.

2 other members rated this 4.0

2 other members rated this 3.5

6 other members rated this 3.0

3 other members rated this 2.5

1 other member rated this 2.0


Explore


Before you go, check out more —
X