Highest Rated

Benriach 35  •  8/25/2016  •  4.5

Vanilla on the nose. Great nose. A very distinctive flavor that I cannot put my finger on. Very drinkable. Marshmallows? Marshmallows! Love this.

Dockside Exclusive Blended Malt Whisky  •  7/27/2016  •  4.5

A slight sweetness, no peat. I could drink a bottle of this.

Copperworks American Single Malt Whiskey  •  9/29/2016  •  4.0

Jurassic park amber color. Very sweet on the nose. Apple, banana, with added sugar. From concentrate. Coppery mid notes. Doesn't linger. Scratch that, totally does, builds after a minute. Gets hotter as it lingers. Agave syrup sweetness. PEPPERMINT. Butterscotch nose. Gets better every time I come back to it.

Lowest Rated

Appleton Special Gold  •  4/28/2016  •  2.0

Spiked simple syrup. Buttery. Add soda water and an ice cube and you'd have a nice summer drink.

Bainbridge Yama  •  9/29/2016  •  3.0

Super ripe bananas on the nose. Almost smells like the way banana candy tastes. Tastes like bananas too. Is this distilled from banana peels? Even looks like water would if you left bananas in it for a while.

Catoctin Creek Dia de los Muertos Whiskey  •  4/27/2017  •  3.0

Sharpie nose. Like drinking the oil from a fragrance diffuser, but sweeter than I would imagine that the oil would be.


Before you go, check out more —