3.00/5
RATING

Polly's Cask

Tullibardine ⋅ Bottled by Alexander Murray
40% ABV
$115

A unique partnership between Alexander Murray independent bottlers, Tullibardine, and Firestone Brewing has brought us this Scotch aged in barrels that were ex-bourbon, then ex-pale ale. The Tullibardine purchased by Alexander Murray has no age statement, but it is aged one year in the casks from the Firestone Double Barrel Ale.

We tasted Polly's Cask at Meeting No. 85 on October 24, 2019. We rated it very highly at 3.00 out of 5, though we had some disagreement among member ratings. Polly's Cask ranks 9th overall in Scotch. At a street price of $115, this spirit is on the pricier side given the our rating of it.

Rating Details

AVERAGE
RATING
3.00/5
FOUNDERS
2.50/5
MEMBERS
3.33/5
AGREEMENT
VALUE
RANK
No. 9 of 13
RANK
No. 108 of 124
RATING BASED ON
10 Reviews
BEST FOR

Tasting Notes

First Tasted at Meeting No. 85 in October 2019

Steve  •   •  4.5

Creamy, smooth (Of course... How could you have creamy and not smooth?)

Natasha  •   •  4.0

Caraway seeds, caramel, peppers. Fireside spice and all things nice.

Garrett  •   •  0.5

Very much just a sharp beer. Not a favorite. Couldn’t drink much of this. Blah. Smells like a cardboard fart.

1 other member rated this 4.0

2 other members rated this 3.5

1 other member rated this 3.0

2 other members rated this 2.5

1 other member rated this 2.0

 

To taste and review spirits like this one, join The Seattle Spirits Society!


Explore


Before you go, check out more —
X