4.74/5
RATING

Pappy Van Winkle’s Family Reserve 23yr

Old Rip Van Winkle Distillery ⋅ Bottled by Buffalo Trace
23 Years Old
47.8% ABV
$828

We tasted Pappy Van Winkle’s Family Reserve 23yr at Meeting No. 33 on February 26, 2015. We rated it exceptionally at 4.74 out of 5. Pappy Van Winkle’s Family Reserve 23yr is the top rated Bourbon that we've tried. At a street price of $828, this spirit is expensive, but well worth the high price tag.

Rating Details

AVERAGE
RATING
4.74/5
FOUNDERS
4.75/5
MEMBERS
4.73/5
AGREEMENT
VALUE
RANK
No. 1 of 30
RANK
No. 1 of 38
RATING BASED ON
17 Reviews
BEST FOR

Tasting Notes

First Tasted at Meeting No. 33 in February 2015

Meru  •   •  5.0

Dark Amber color Indian spices on the nose - cumin, curry, pepper Opens up to vanilla and then caramel apple pie Tobacco on the palette, nice structure and spice

Darren  •   •  5.0

Full sweet and pleasant aroma. First taste was a sweet grassy, dry wood shop taste. Second taste was a delicious buttery maple syrup flavor.

Kevin  •   •  5.0

Age has treated this treated this spirit kindly. All those dark notes--Graham craxker, syrup, cinnamon, chocolate, root beer, anise--have all melded into one beautiful symphony. Just magnificent. *Mic drop*

Elliott  •   •  5.0

Wonderful, full nose - Cherry syrup, spice, and Kentucky Potpourri. Complex. Gentle, slow-rolling, tongue-covering stuff. The hype had me to believe this was too old. Nay I say. So deep I can't see the end.

Matt G.  •   •  4.5

I'm so excited to drink this, so I'm making it a ceremony. Smelling this gives me no hints of anything except some sweet. I warm it up and swirl it to condensation and sniff again, to which I'm met with caramel, nutmeg, and sugar. Still can't drink, Justin keeps talking.... Finally, taking my first taste melts into a blend of vanilla and cherry chocolate. As I drink more, the lingering taste of that caramel I smelt on the nose remains present. A fine celebration of bourbon.

6 other members rated this 5.0

4 other members rated this 4.5

2 other members rated this 4.0

 

To taste and review spirits like this one, join The Seattle Spirits Society!


Explore


Before you go, check out more —
X