3.63/5
RATING

Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 25 Year Old Bourbon

25 Years Old
45.5% ABV
$299

Rhetoric 25 is the sixth and final installment of a series that has been around longer than some distilleries. It started in 2013 with the release of Rhetoric 20, with what parent company Diageo alleges is old stock from the Bernheim Distillery that was actually found in old Stitzel-Weller Warehouses. Needless to say, it’s a complex pedigree. But the whiskey, which was distilled between 1990 and 1993, ended up in their hands, and with a limited number of these gems at their disposal, they elected to release portions of it each year, each time with a higher age statement.

Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 25 Year Old Bourbon was tasted at Meeting No. 78 on March 28, 2019. Out of 5, we rated it very highly at 3.63, though we had some disagreement among member ratings. Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 25 Year Old Bourbon ranks 21st overall in Bourbon. Costing $299, this spirit is expensive, but worth it.

Rating Details

AVERAGE
RATING
3.63/5
FOUNDERS
3.63/5
MEMBERS
3.63/5
AGREEMENT
VALUE
RANK
No. 21 of 50
RANK
No. 25 of 59
RATING BASED ON
20 Reviews
BEST FOR

Tasting Notes

First Tasted at Meeting No. 78 in March 2019

Natasha  •   •  4.5

Elmer’s glue on the nose; roses; kiln-dried oak; sour;

Gavin  •   •  3.5

Creosote nose, exceptional mouth feel: creamy silk with an oaky bite.

Andy  •   •  2.5

Flouride bubble gum nose, complete with styrofoam trays for my teeth. Smooth taste, if you like rubber. Fortunately this one is fun.

Darren  •   •  1.5

Like the pleasant smell of fresh paint. Unfortunately, it tastes a little like paint as well.

3 other members rated this 4.5

6 other members rated this 4.0

5 other members rated this 3.5

1 other member rated this 3.0

1 other member rated this 2.5

 

To taste and review spirits like this one, join The Seattle Spirits Society!


Explore


Before you go, check out more —
X